Experience: i learned to play the piano without a piano

We can say "ride a bike", "drive sầu a car", why should we say "play the piano" instead of "play a piano"?



Contrary to what is being said by other answerers, there is a real reason for this, and it"s not just for musical instruments.

Bạn đang xem: Experience: i learned to play the piano without a piano

We use the phrasing "play the piano" because the piano isn"t technically what is being played - it"s the tool by which music is being played.

We see this type of phrase whenever someone uses the tool as a reference lớn the activity. You "wield the sword" as a swordfighter. You "wield the pen" as an author. You "use the keyboard", you "work the shovel". An alcoholic would "bury themselves in the bottle". An artist would "wield the brush" & a photographer would "wield the camera".

The construction also works with the tool replaced with the... wacsantangelo1907.com, the canvas, or whatever equivalent it might be. A farmer would "work the soil", the artist would "work the canvas", and the travacsantangelo1907.comer would "ride the rail".

Improve sầu this answer
answered Aug 10 "15 at 16:46

Glen OGlen O
73544 silver badges33 bronze badges
| Show 20 more comments
Actually, you can say "play a piano", it just means something different than "play the piano".

We use the definite article when describing the skill of piano playing:

I started learning to play the piano at six years old.

We use the indefinite article in all the same places as you use it for "ride a bike".

I prefer lớn play a piano a couple of times before deciding to lớn buy it.

We use the definite article for describing the skill of playing any musical instrument; we don"t bởi vì that for non-musical instruments. So:

I want to lớn learn to play the piano.

I want to lớn learn to ride a bike.

But also correct are both:

I want to lớn learn lớn play piano.

I want khổng lồ learn to ride bikes.

It would be technically correct but very unidiomatic lớn say:

I want to learn lớn play pianos.

Improve this answer
edited Jun 16 "đôi mươi at 9:11

answered Aug 10 "15 at 7:52

8,25722 gold badges1313 silver badges3232 bronze badges
| Show 6 more comments
In "play a piano" the word "piano" will mean a particular single physical instrument.

Xem thêm: Bạn Có Biết: 1 Hải Lý Bằng Bao Nhiêu Km Đường Bộ? 1 Hải Lý Bằng Bao Nhiêu Km

In "play the piano" the word "piano" will mean the whole class of instruments.

Both are valid but with different meanings, so correct usage depends on the intended message.

Improve sầu this answer
answered Aug 10 "15 at 18:38
53833 silver badges99 bronze badges
Add a bình luận |
We use "the" with any named chiến thắng from a set of items of the same category.

Have sầu you ever taken the redeye from LA to lớn NY? (category: scheduled flights between those hubs)

I always take the express lớn work in the morning, but coming home page I take the 6:15 Local out of 30th Street Station. (category: trains on the schedule)

Do you play the trombone? (category: musical instrument types)

Have you driven the năm ngoái Mercedes Gelaendewagen? (category: vehicle models or vehicle models from Mercedes)

Have sầu you tried the strawberry cheesecake at that restaurant? (category: desserts served at that restaurant)

I can"t wait to try out the iPhone 6. (category: smartphone models)

I"ve never operated the M841. (category: microscope models made by Leica)

But we would say:

I"ve never ridden a zebra.

Phường.S. But we can create a context where "the zebra" would be used:

I"ve sầu ridden many a four-legged beast: the hippo, the rhino, the onager, & the horse, of course, but never the zebra.

Improve this answer
edited Aug 10 "15 at 23:47
answered Aug 10 "15 at 20:10
118k77 gold badges9393 silver badges193193 bronze badges
| Show 1 more phản hồi
There is no logical reason for the use of "the" + musical instrumement. It is simply an idiomatic matter. Maybe there is French influence, though in French it is "jouer du piano" (to lớn play of the piano; I have never found out how this genitive can be explained; but "du" is a khung of the definite article).

Improve this answer
answered Aug 10 "15 at 15:35
8,48622 gold badges20đôi mươi silver badges2424 bronze badges
| Show 5 more comments
As a Grammar rule in AE, when you refer to playing a musical instrument, you usually use the definite article in front of the instrument, though omitting "the" is also possible For example:

He plays the flute/piano/guitar/clarinet, etc.

On the other hvà, when you refer to lớn a musical instrument as a unit, you can use the indefinite article. For examples:

I have a piano. There"s a guitar on the table.

Interestingly, when you refer to sports or games, you don"t use any article such as "He plays tennis/cricket/volleyball, etc.

Improve this answer
edited Jun 12 "19 at 20:50
109k99 gold badges154154 silver badges278278 bronze badges
answered Aug 10 "15 at 7:10
26.8k11 gold badge2424 silver badges4949 bronze badges
Add a comment |
I"m guessing here, but I think the correct answer is that piano is being used in two different ways.

We say:

"I learnt khổng lồ see the future" to lớn indicate a specific future."I learnt to build a house" khổng lồ indicate a generic house."I learnt lớn speak the language" lớn indicate a specific language."I learnt to speak a language" to indicate a language without specifying which one.

So if you say I learnt to lớn play the piano, you"re saying that you learnt the skill of playing a specific type of keyboard instrument... the piano referring to lớn specific knowledge rather than a specific object. The the is associated with the implied skill & not with piano.If referring khổng lồ the object you over up with I learnt lớn repair a piano, communicating that your ability isn"t specific khổng lồ a single particular piano.

Xem thêm: Bài Viết Về Chuyến Du Lịch Bằng Tiếng Anh Hay Nhất, Cách Viết Đoạn Văn Tiếng Anh Về Chuyến Du Lịch

I can play the piano = I have sầu a specific skill.I can play a piano = I can operate any piano.I can play that piano = I can operate the specific piano being indicated.

Chuyên mục: Tổng hợp